I was recently brought into an organization to write an anthem film at a pivotal moment. They were rolling out a new vision.
My three executive stakeholders and I were aligned: the main job of the film was to get company-wide buy-in and stir up motivation and pride.
After the first exploratory script territories, the film soon began taking on other jobs.
It now also needed to acknowledge the organization’s past. After all, they were building on a strong history; the new film shouldn’t suggest their evolution was a wholesale pivot rather than a natural one.
Next, the film also needed to represent different parts of the organization. All contributed. People needed to see themselves.
Just one more. The film also had to preserve established language. Someone had worked hard to wrangle agreement on those words. People would be expecting to see them.
None of the new requirements above were frivolous. But every single one would take up scriptspace, and each addition would siphon away attention from the film’s big idea.
When anything starts to say too much, it starts to say nothing. I mentioned to the stakeholders that with the new additions, the script was now losing what had made it compelling and fresh. After a bit of back and forth, we started discussing how to restore the focus we’d started with.
With three execs dropping into review sessions, the work got organizationally more expensive. There’s really no blame to assign. Their points were valid. But another pass at a script means another review. And when the job remains open, as this one did well into production, late changes mean changes to the voiceover, the timing, the pictures. The work kept moving while the guiding decisions remained unresolved.
When anything starts to say too much, it starts to say nothing.
At a certain point, and I recommend at the front end, a decision has to be made about which of all the important things actually belong in this film.
It’s never unclear who outranks whom in the rooms I work in. What is frequently less clear, however, is what outranks what.
When a room has several good criteria and no agreed-upon ranking, things get settled informally, in real time. At least until they come up again. What I’ve noticed is that whoever proposes a change first can tilt the room, making it feel like a decision’s been made before anyone’s had a chance to sit with it. Time is money and sometimes momentum is favored over meaning. People like a decision and sometimes the quickest answer is the proxy.
You’ll never hear me claim to be the fastest person in any room. Nor do I aim to be. What I am is persistent. I don’t treat a revision proposed in a meeting as decided, and I’ll keep raising a point until it’s truly settled. But persistence is a workaround, not a system.
The problem with colliding priorities isn’t always disagreement, per se. People can agree that every addition suggested is valuable. But what they’re frequently not discussing is what the additions collectively push out of sight or focus.
How much can we promise?
On a different recent brand anthem project I was working on with two execs, we were trying to connect an optimistic human idea to a convincing role for the company.
At some point, both executives took a pass at bits of the script themselves. They acknowledged they weren’t copywriters, but they had thoughts they wanted to try.
I don’t love feedback delivered as a rewrite. It takes work to tease apart the intent from the proposed language. In the end, I usually need to schedule a round of follow-up questions. Nevertheless, I waited for their rewrites and put their versions next to mine. What the revisions showed me was what they wanted the company to do in the story: remove all doubt from their audiences, give them greater confidence, make the brand promise feel consequential.
While that direction made the company’s role clearer, it also raised a question about whether it was pressing the bounds of believability. How credible is proposed language that implies the company could remove uncertainty? If you think you can remove uncertainty, you’ll soon discover how much uncertainty legal can add back in.
With the next draft of the script, I sent a note explaining to the execs what I’d taken from each of their versions. I also explained what I intended to preserve: keep the emotional altitude of the anthem while making the company’s role clearer. I didn’t suggest eliminating uncertainty, but being the company that could convincingly manage it.
Give what’s cut somewhere to go
I’m not arguing for one person’s criterion to always win. Rather, I’m arguing that importance alone isn’t sovereign.
In the first film, every part of the organization needed to see itself. But did each need its own explanation, or could the central idea and the graphics do that work? And where fuller explanation was needed, did it belong in the film? In an executive memo? On the intranet? A town hall?
As a writer, you can make a case for removing a passage. As a marketing lead, you can decide where that explanation belongs instead. A cut is easier to make when it doesn’t mean losing it altogether. In this case, the fuller explanation wound up in the executive memo I co-wrote.
What governs the next round?
The note I sent with the second anthem made my judgments obvious so they could agree or disagree.
The person running a review can do the same before another draft is written:
For this piece, ___ is sovereign, ___ is protected, and we’ll include ___ if there’s room.
To determine if a suggestion is knocking you off course, run it through the filter. Does a request help fulfill the agreement? Does it change the agreement? Does it belong somewhere else?
That’s the work I’ve come to think matters most in a review. Ask “is this needed?” and “at what expense?” Until the room knows what it’s optimizing for, “needed” can open the door to almost anything.
If you try the prompt in your next review, I’d like to hear what happened.
hello@utterverbal.comGet it by email
